Third World Approaches to International Law (TWAIL) and State Responsibility in Light of Iran’s Developments

Document Type : Original Independent Original Article

Authors

1 Assistant Professor, Department of Public International Law, Bu.C., Islamic Azad University, Bushehr, Iran

2 PhD Student in Public International Law, Department of Law, Bu.C., Islamic Azad University, Bushehr, Iran; MA in English Translation; Lecturer at Erm Higher Education Institute, Shiraz, Iran

Abstract
Traditional international law, by offering universal rules, claims to regulate inter-state relations impartially; however, this universality does not necessarily entail actual equality in the formation and enforcement of rules. The main question of this research is how disregarding structural inequalities and uniformly applying standards such as due diligence without considering the actual capacities of developing countries can lead to disproportionate outcomes. These challenges are vividly manifested in Iran’s contemporary developments, such as unilateral sanctions, violations of state jurisdictional immunity, and double standards in human rights assessments. Employing a descriptive-analytical method and utilizing the critical framework of the “Third World Approaches to International Law” (TWAIL), this paper analyzes the challenges facing the international state responsibility regime. The findings indicate that responsibility rules, within the context of unequal power relations, sometimes turn into instruments for reproducing hegemony and imposing disproportionate expectations on Global South countries. The conclusion emphasizes the necessity of moving toward a pluralistic and justice-oriented system; a transformation that requires strengthening South-South convergences, rethinking obligation assessment criteria by factoring in states’ actual capacities, and enriching indigenous legal doctrines to achieve substantive sovereign equality and counter unilateral coercive measures.

Keywords

Subjects